Every now and again, board members will encounter the threat of HOA lawsuits. When that happens, it is imperative to know how to proceed. Better yet, boards should take the necessary steps to prevent liability exposure in the first place. This will help keep the HOA in the clear and financially stable.
What are HOA Lawsuits?
Homeowners association lawsuits are legal actions that homeowners bring against their HOA or board. These lawsuits typically stem from disputes over rules, property maintenance, fiduciary duties, or financial mismanagement.
Left unaddressed, these lawsuits can quickly turn into full-blown court litigation. At this point, the association would need to pour significant resources into defending itself or its board. While insurance can cover some costs, the HOA’s finances could still take a significant hit, jeopardizing long-term financial solvency.
Common Causes of Lawsuits Against the HOA Board
Lawsuits can arise due to a number of reasons. In some cases, it doesn’t even take much for an owner to threaten the board with a lawsuit. That said, it is still important to understand what usually triggers lawsuits, so that boards can prepare in advance.
Here are the common causes of HOA lawsuits.
- Maintenance Negligence. Suing HOA for negligence can happen when the association board fails to repair common areas. These include roofs, pipes, and sidewalks.
- Improper Rule Enforcement. When an HOA selectively enforces rules, such as parking, architectural changes, or pet policies, it can lead to legal action from owners.
- Financial Mismanagement. Lawsuits based on this often involve the misuse of funds, unfair special assessments, or a lack of transparency.
- Discrimination. Owners might sue their HOA for violations of fair housing laws, often related to disability accommodation or familial status.
- Unfair Board Elections. If the board follows improper procedures or outright refuses to hold legitimate elections, owners can file a lawsuit against it.
- Harassment. Suing HOA for harassment happens when there are repeated or intentional actions deemed threatening or abusive.
How to Respond to Legal Actions Against the HOA
A civil lawsuit often begins when a homeowner files a case with the court. The HOA or its board will then receive a summons. A summons is a legal document or order that requires the HOA to answer a lawsuit.
Once the HOA board receives this summons, it is important to act quickly. Associations must usually meet a strict deadline; otherwise, penalties will ensue. This deadline can vary by case or location, but it is typically 30 days.
At this point, the board must immediately contact the association’s attorney. The HOA attorney can review the summons and draft an answer. They can also advise the board on the next steps.
Additionally, the board should contact the association’s insurance provider. The association’s general liability and D&O insurance, in particular, will come in handy. Immediate notification can ensure prompt and proper coverage of the related costs.
Key Protections Against HOA Board Lawsuits
Board members aren’t left totally defenseless against legal action. Personal liability tends to be limited, especially if the board acted in good faith.
There are three key concepts that protect the board from liability: the governing documents, the business judgment rule, and fiduciary duty. Let’s discuss them below.
Governing Documents
The CC&Rs and bylaws act as the primary source of the board’s authority. If the association breaks its own rules, owners are bound to take action.
Business Judgment Rule
This rule protects board members from personal liability, provided they acted:
- In good faith,
- With reasonable care, and
- In the best interest of the association.
Fiduciary Duty
Board members have a legal responsibility to put the community first at all times. This means making decisions that benefit the association, not themselves or individual owners.
How to Avoid HOA Lawsuits
Lawsuits can be costly and time-consuming, so it’s better to prevent them altogether than to respond to them once they arise. Here are the strategies boards can use to avoid HOA lawsuits.
1. Enforce Rules Consistently
Fair enforcement is integral to keeping the association in the clear. Board members should always apply the rules evenly and uniformly to all homeowners. This will help the board avoid accusations of selective enforcement, bias, or favoritism.
2. Maintain Common Areas
Many homeowners complain about the lack of common-area maintenance, even escalating the issue to court. To avoid this, boards should hire vendors to regularly inspect and repair the association’s properties.
3. Ensure Fair Housing Compliance
A lawyer won’t always be around to advise the board on what to do and say. For this reason, board members should know the basics of the Fair Housing Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act. This will help them prevent allegations of discrimination.
4. Ensure Fair Elections
Given that elections are a common source of disputes, boards can reduce liability exposure by ensuring fair and legitimate elections. This means following strict procedures and requirements for elections and voting.
5. Utilize Alternative Dispute Resolution
Mediation and arbitration are speedier and cheaper alternatives to a lawsuit. In some cases, they are even required before an owner or the HOA itself pursues litigation.
6. Be Transparent
Homeowners’ frustrations often stem from a lack of transparency. When the board fails to share project details, budget summaries, and financial records with the membership, it can look a lot like the board is hiding something. This can also lead to perceived mismanagement.
How an HOA Management Company Helps
While it is good to have an attorney within reach, board members can benefit greatly by hiring an HOA management company. Here are the ways a company like this can help.
Acts as the First Responder
Management companies serve as the first line of defense when there is a legal threat. Once the board receives a summons, the manager can gauge the severity of the situation. The manager can also make sure that the board contacts both the attorney and the insurance carrier.
Ideally, the lawsuit won’t proceed. If it does, the management company can begin gathering all necessary documents to help the association’s defense.
Mitigates Risks
While the HOA management company doesn’t act as a defense counsel, it can help reduce legal exposure. To do this, the company can schedule regular property inspections, enforce rules consistently, and maintain transparency.
Complies With Operational Procedures
Board members may have difficulty interpreting legal documents, including the CC&Rs and bylaws. A management company can help with this, ensuring all elections, meetings, and enforcement actions follow the governing documents to the letter.
Resolves Conflicts
Disputes are a normal part of any neighborhood. An HOA management company can act as a neutral third party to mediate these conflicts, helping the board de-escalate the situation before the owner decides to file a lawsuit.
Advice for Homeowners
Suing an HOA may sound like a good idea at first, but it is not always the best course of action. When homeowners are dissatisfied with the HOA, they should first consider speaking with the board directly. A simple conversation is sometimes all it takes to resolve an issue.
If that does not work, ADR methods are available. Both mediation and arbitration are more affordable and less time-consuming than litigation. Mediation is even preferable because it helps both parties reach a mutually beneficial agreement.
HOA lawsuits should be a last resort. Considering the HOA receives its funds from owner dues, the homeowner will indirectly be paying for the association’s defense.
Better Than Cure
HOA lawsuits can end up crippling the association financially and damaging its reputation. While knowing how to respond to them is important, prevention is even more critical. Board members should implement the strategies above, including hiring an HOA management company, to avoid legal exposure.
Cedar Management Group provides effective management services to HOAs and condo associations, including legal compliance. Call us today at (877) 252-3327 or email us at help@mycmg.com to get started!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- How To Reduce HOA Legal Costs Without Increasing Risk
- Start the Year Right With an HOA Insurance Policy Review
- Identifying And Mitigating Cyber Risks In HOAs
