The topic of majority in the HOA board comes up more often than people might expect. And in many cases, it can completely shape how the board acts and also how the community feels about decisions. But majorities can be dangerous, especially if the board consistently defaults to it, no matter their opinion or viewpoint.
Understanding the Minority and Majority in the HOA Board
When it comes to minority-majority dynamics on HOA boards, it is not always as simple as saying one group wins a single vote and another loses. It is more about how certain directors tend always to align, no matter the issue on the table.
In the end, this constant alignment creates a block, which becomes the majority group. The rest who get left behind form the minority.
Boards are usually set up with an odd number of directors to prevent tie votes. Yet, this also sets the stage for divisions. For example, in a five-member board, three directors voting together consistently can essentially control the outcome every time. The other two directors can speak and raise concerns, but at the end of the day, their voices get drowned out.
It is normal for board members to disagree on issues. Debate actually helps bring out different points of view. That said, if the same three or four directors always overpower the others, then the process no longer feels fair.
Homeowners will start to feel like only a handful of people are calling the shots, while others sit on the sidelines. When that happens repeatedly, the minority directors may start to check out. They will begin to question the point of voting if they already know how every vote will go.
The same applies to condo associations. When condo boards consistently have the same people voting for or against certain issues, it can create a divide.
How Board Division Affects the HOA Community
The presence of a majority in HOA board decisions does not stay in the boardroom. It leaks out and trickles down, and residents notice it in more ways than one. Division among directors creates division among homeowners. Once that trust is gone, it is very hard to repair.
Here are the ways board majorities negatively impact the community.
1. Loss of Trust
Homeowners trust the board to act in everyone’s best interests. When the same majority keeps pushing its agenda, residents start to doubt that trust. For instance, if projects consistently focus on the majority’s section of the neighborhood, the rest feel ignored. This makes homeowners think the board is serving a few, not the many.
2. Decreased Participation
If residents believe the outcome is already decided by the majority, they might see no reason to attend meetings or volunteer. This attitude can spread quickly. Meetings become emptier, committees lack volunteers, and voter turnout falls. The board ends up with less homeowner input, which only makes the majority’s grip stronger.
3. Conflict Among Residents
Neighbors will also start taking sides. Some might support the majority, while others support the minority. This can create gossip, arguments, and even hostility. On the other hand, if the board shows unity, residents follow that example and stay cooperative.
4. Unfair Policy Outcomes
The majority can pass rules that reflect their interests more than the community’s. For example, they may enforce landscaping or parking rules that mainly benefit their own homes. This breeds resentment. Sometimes, it even leads to legal disputes, and everyone will have to shoulder the burden of the legal fees.
5. Slow or Stalled Progress
Surprisingly, having a strong majority does not always speed things up. The minority may resist, stall, or question every move. Repairs, upgrades, or even routine maintenance can slow down. Everyone in the community pays the price for this constant tug of war.
Majority in HOA Board: A Problem in Decision-Making
When a majority in HOA board settings keeps control of everything, the decision-making process can break down. It may look efficient on paper, but in reality, it will shut out different perspectives.
The minority directors lose their ability to influence. Their input is brushed aside, discouraging them from contributing. Over time, the majority becomes bolder, and the board’s culture changes. It starts to feel less like a shared effort and more like a dictatorship type setup.
With too much concentrated power, mistakes are bound to follow. Contracts may go to the friends of the majority, budgets may lean toward specific projects, and oversight gets weaker. When no one questions the majority, minor errors grow into bigger problems. In some cases, this path can lead to financial misconduct or even criminal behavior.
Ways to Prevent a Majority in the HOA Board
Preventing a majority in the HOA board from dominating requires effort. It is not easy, but the board must try. Here are some ways to keep balance.
1. Encourage Open Debate
Directors must hear each other out. Even if discussions take longer, giving space for minority views will only benefit the community in the long run. For example, before voting on a new amenity project, every director should explain their reasoning. This way, the board can avoid jumping to decisions without thought.
2. Adopt Clear Rules of Order
Using meeting procedures, such as Robert’s Rules, helps structure the discussion. These rules allow minority directors to make motions, raise objections, and record their dissent. Without such an order, the majority can silence the minority.
3. Rotate Officer Roles
If the same people remain as president or treasurer for years, power can accumulate. By rotating officer roles, the board can spread out influence. It also gives more directors leadership experience, which can help with decision-making.
4. Create Independent Committees
Committees made up of non-board members can help reduce board dominance. A finance or architectural review committee can provide outside input. When residents outside the board evaluate issues, the majority can’t control everything.
5. Promote Homeowner Involvement
The more residents attend meetings and review reports, the more accountable the board becomes. A strong majority can’t ignore a room full of homeowners demanding answers.
6. Transparency in Records
Publishing board votes and financial decisions can expose patterns, particularly negative ones. If homeowners see the same group always voting together, they may push for change in elections.
7. Seek Mediation When Necessary
When divisions become severe, the board can call in a mediator. A neutral party can help refocus directors on serving the community as a whole. It may not fix everything, but it can prevent a complete breakdown.
For the Good of Everyone
In the end, the danger of a majority in the HOA board comes from imbalance. The board must work as a team and avoid antagonizing one another, especially since the good of the community is at stake. By ensuring transparency and fairness, associations can provide good governance and service.
Cedar Management Group provides effective management services to HOAs and condo associations, including help with insurance. Call us today at (877) 252-3327 or email us at help@mycmg.com to get started!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- How To Remove HOA Board Members And Other Questions Answered
- What Constitutes An Illegal HOA Board Meeting
- How To Handle Bullies On Your HOA Board
